Machinereadable bibliographic record marc, ris, bibtex document object identifier doi. Yet, they find no risk premium associated with this systematic risk. Kaplan and zingales 1997 provide both theoretical arguments and empirical evidence that investmentcash flow sensitivities are not good indicators of financing constraints. Previous versions of this paper kaplan and zingales 1995 circulated under the title do. Kaplan and zingales 1997 and cleary 1999 diverge from the large literature on investmentcash ow sensitivity by showing that investment is most sensitive to cash ow for the least. Investmentcash flow sensitivities are not valid measures. Investmentcash flow sensitivities are not valid measures of financing constraints. Sep 30, 2016 on the other hand, allayannis and mozumdar show that the kaplan and zingales results may have been influenced by possible outliers and by firms that face financial distress. For example, using bond ratings as a criterion, we assign all the. The roles of expected profitability, tobins q and cash flow in econometric models of company investment. Firms as buyers of last resort columbia university. Previous versions of this paper kaplan and zingales 1995 circulated under the title do financing.
We find that firms that appear less financially constrained exhibit significantly greater sensitivities than firms that appear more financially constrained. In this framework investment is chosen so that the marginal revenue product of capital is equated. Kaplan and zingales 1997 provide both theoretical arguments and empirical. A survey of corporate governance shleifer 1997 the. This paper investigates the relationship between financing constraints and investmentcash flow sensitivities by analyzing the firms identified by fazzari, hubbard, and petersen as having unusually high investmentcash flow sensitivities. Pdf do investmentcash flow sensitivities provide useful. Using negative cash flows as proxy for financial constraints and by removing some of the outliers in the kaplan and zingales 1997 study, allayannis and mozumdar 2004.
Moreover, our theory predicts that this relation should be. As a result, the m odel can reproduce quantitatively the empirical evidences of fazzari, hubbard and peterson 1988 and kaplan. On the other hand, allayannis and mozumdar show that the kaplan and zingales results may have been influenced by possible outliers and by firms that face financial distress. Payout flexibility and capital expenditure springerlink. They show that under certain assumptions, investmentcash flow sensitivities may increase as financing constraints are relaxed. Aug 11, 2000 kaplan, steven neil and zingales, luigi, do financing constraints explain why investment is correlated with cash flow. These indexes are assumed to be better measures of financial constraints. Bank lending, financing constraints and sme investment.
Investmentcanbenancedeitherwithinternalfundsworwithexternalfundse. The firm uses internal and external financing, the latter is associated with additional cost. The quarterly journal of economics 112 1, 169215, 1997. Kaplan and zingales 1997, 2000 question the validity of this interpretation. Financing constraints and firms cash policy in the euro area. Firms as buyers of last resort harrison hong princeton university jiang wang mit and ccfr jialin yu.
Review and evaluation on do investmentcash flow sensitivities provide useful measures of financing constraints by kaplan and zingales qje, 1997 the research paper written by steven n. Financial constraints, asset tangibility, andcorporate. By taking this approach, as opposed to building our own measure of equity dependence from scratch, we hope to minimize any concerns about data mining. Do investmentcash flow sensitivities provide useful. Kaplan and zingales 1997 study the sensitivity of investment to the availability of internal nance for rms that face di. Do financing constraints explain why investment is correlated with. Tax policy and heterogeneous investment behavior eric zwick and james mahon the views expressed here are the authors and do not necessarily re ect those of the internal revenue service or the o ce of tax analysis.
With 185 centers and over 1,200 classroom locations throughout the u. The impact of financial constraints on the convertible bond. Kaplan and zingales 1997 develop a simple model to show that even if firms face differing degrees of financing constraints, it is not necessarily the. No 7659, nber working papers from national bureau of economic research, inc abstract. Lamont, polk, and saarequejo 2001 estimate an ordered logit model relating the degree of financial constraints according to kaplan and zingales 1997 classification to five readily available. Pdf financing constraints and industry classification. Kaplan and zingales kz index, 1997 using a textbased approach that has proved popular, kaplan and zingales 1997 challenge fhps conclusions. Pdf cash flow, profitability, financial constraint, and investment. This kz index has already been adapted for use in largesample empirical work by lamont, polk, and saarequejo 2001, so we can follow their methodology. I follow kaplan and zingales 1997 and construct a simple one period model of a representative firm that maximizes profits from investment. Corporate social responsibility and access to finance. A comment on kaplan and zingales article pdf available in quarterly journal of economics 1152. Kaplan and zingales 1997 in a study published in 1997 classify firms into discrete categories of financial constraint and relate these classifications to accounting variables. Contrary to kaplan and zingales 1997 s argument, the model illustrates that existence of unutilized credit lines is compatible with the presence of.
For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing. Do financing constraints explain why investment is. Kz index, first advocated by kaplan and zingales 1997 and subsequently used extensively in the corporate finance literature e. Investmentcash flow sensitivities are not valid measures of. We examine if this result can be explained by the fact that when.
Benjamin bridgman and violet law provided excellent research assistance. Comments from charles calomiris, john cochrane, zsuzsanna fluck. Do investmentcash flow sensitivities provide useful measures of financing constraints. Financial constraints, asset tangibility, andcorporate investment. On the other hand, kaplan and zingales 1997 disagree with fazzari et al. Kaplan test prep and admissions has helped more than 3 million students achieve their educational and career goals.
Fazzari, hubbard and petersen contend that firms with larger coefficient estimates on cash flows are likely to be more financially constrained. Kaplan, steven neil and zingales, luigi, do financing constraints explain why investment is correlated with cash flow. If company experiences high financial constraint, then they will tend to use higher. In a recent paper in this journal kaplan and zingales 1997, hereinafter kz argue that investmentcash flow sensitivities do not provide useful evidence about. Fazzari, hubbard and petersen 1999 criticize those findings. Previous versions of this paper kaplan and zingales 1995 circulated under the title do financing constraints explain why investment is correlated with cash flow. Kaplan and luigi zingales as titled above which was published in year 1997 is to test the relationship linking investmentcash flow with financial constraint. However, their focus is on a different question how investmentcash flow sensitivities vary with financial constraints and they never discuss or. See chirinko 1993 for a broad survey of the empirical literature in inveslment.
Kaplan and zingales 1995, hereafter kz criticize fazzari, hubbard and petersen 1988, hereafter fhp and much ensuing research that uses crosssectional differences in firm behavior to test for financing constraints on investment. Selected bibliography for luigi zingales the university of. Kaplan and zingales 1997 criticize this approach and with a simple oneperiod model of investment show that the sensitivity may not be monotonically increasing in the degree of nancing constraints in the cross section. The impact of negative cash flow and inuential observations. Do financing constraints explain why investment is correlated. Index of lectures fabio schiantarelli with ana lariau and mikhail dmitriev fall 2014 boston college lecture 0. Almeida and campello 2001 draw similar conclusions. Kaplan and zingales 1997 argue that the monotonicity hypothesis is not a necessary property of optimal constrained investment, and report evidence that contradicts fazzari et al. Language planning from practice to theory robert b. There are many reasons to believe that a manager will behave risk. The roles of expected profitability, tobins q and cash. Selected bibliography for luigi zingales the university. Conditional investmentcash flow sensitivities and financing. Do investmentcash flow sensitivities provide useful measures of.
Silanes, raghu rajan, david scharfstein, rene stulz, and luigi zingales for comments, and to the nsf for financial support. Kaplan and zingales 1997 classify firms into discrete categories of financial constraint and then use an ordered logit regression to relate their classifications to. A comment on kaplan and zingales, the quarterly journal of economics, oxford university press, vol. Investment cash flow sensitivities really reflect related. They find that financially constrained firms stock returns move together over time, suggesting that constrained firms are subject to common shocks. Do investmentcash flow sensitivities provide useful measures. We also include the kaplan zingales index kz, kaplan and zingales 1997 to control for the impact of nancial constraints. We depart from the kaplan zingales model by assuming a stochastic world and risk aversion of the.
Review on kaplan and zingales research paper about. While kaplan and zingales 1997 use information from the firms management reports and financial statements for the apriori classification, we define different. The kaplan zingales model assumes a deterministic setting so the risk attitude of the decisionmaker is irrelevant. Pdf a recent paper in this journal by kaplan and zingales reexamines. As an explanation for these controversial and conflicting results, kaplan and zingales 2000 suggest that unobserved changes in environmental conditions such as changes in firm.
142 1030 384 1605 1035 377 304 530 645 843 46 396 1550 172 620 88 394 1073 853 1411 1311 922 1023 1486 1647 418 1116 492 223 1200 911 206 181 1248 366 104 492 1474 1242 1383